Amish Chrsitmas at North Star by Cindy Woodsmall, Mindy Starns Clark and Emily Clark, Amanda Flower, and Katie Ganshert. These well known authors have worked together to write this delightful book of 4 stories. The premise of the story is that Rebekah, the midwife of the Amish community 25 years ago on a snowy night delivered 4 babies and these 4 stories are how they are spending this Christmas as adults. The children are Elle McAllister, Eden Hochstetler, Savilla Beiler, and Andy Danner. In the first Elle knows that she is adopted but has no idea that her mother was from the Amish community of North Star. A local reporter, Chase Wellington, decides to write a story about the 4 births and has set out to find out what happened to all those children born on that snowy night. He becomes intrigued when he finds that one of the Amish women disappeared from the community after being dismissed and was never heard of after that. Elle the baby of that mother has had a good life being raised by good parents, knows that her biological mother is out there but has no burning desire to find her, assuming that her mother does not want to be found. Chase convinces her that she should go back to North Star from Iowa where she was raised to find out her family history.
In the 2nd story, Eden has joined with her non-Amish friend, Gina, to solve a murder mystery. Eden's good elderly friend, Isaac, was found dead in the stable that he owned in town. On the surface it looked like an accident where a horse stomped the man to death but Gina's father was the veterinarian and told her that the horse had a puncture wound and the lab results from the autopsy showed that the horse had been injected with amphetamines. This greatly upset Eden since she was very close to the older man and loved spending time at the stables with him. So begins the solving of the mystery by the two girls.
In the 3rd story Savilla has broken off her engagement to Kore without much explanation. Savilla though had what she thought was an excellent reason, she was not going to be able to have children because she had to have a hysterectomy and didn't want Kore to marry her just because he felt sorry for her. So she broke off the engagement without telling him why. But when Kore's, grandmother Mammi D. falls and is in critical condition at the local hospital and Kore needs to come back home to help out. Savilla has gone to check out Mammi D's house and make sure all was as it should be. Savilla had been working with Mammi D the day before she fell and she needed to finish up and also wanted to check and make sure it hadn't left something out and caused the fall. She heard a noise while she was there and discovered 3 children hiding outside. She found out the Mammi D had agreed to watch them while their parents were out of the country to adopt their next sibling. Savilla and Kore have to learn to get along and start working together to care for the children so that their parents don't have to return before the adoption goes through.
In the 4th story Andy Danner has left North Star 6 months ago because he can't face life there after Nellie left him. Nellie always had been good with numbers and wanted to continue her education at the university. She thought that though she could go through with joining the church and marriage to Andy until that day she left classes at the church and tearfully told him that she couldn't do it. Nellie had gone on to the city and tried classes but found that she really needed the church and loved Andy more than she wanted to be educated. Nellie returned to North Star and repented and was accepted back into the church and community but Andy couldn't trust her and he left for Mississippi to join an Amish group working construction. Sam, Andy's 12 year old brother was devastated as was Nellie. Nellie wrote to Andy and apologized and said she would wait as long as necessary and went to work in an ice cream parlor in town and sewing for people on the side. Sam thought of a great idea, he would make all the money necessary to buy Andy's train ticket if he would agree to come home. Andy thinking it was impossible agreed. Then Sam went to Nellie and talked to her about Andy and found the Nellie had written to him already but agreed to write another letter to him to apologize again. All was going good until Andy and Sam's dad had the terrible accident and Sam gave up all his money to help pay the hospital bills.
How is all this going to turn out for these 4 babies born on the same terrible night?